top of page
From the Desk of Matthew Gardner

Explore expert analysis and data-driven perspectives from the Desk of Matthew Gardner.
Through written pieces and videos, he breaks down complex market trends to provide clarity on the ever-evolving real estate landscape.


Should First-Time Buyers Be Able to Buy a Home With Just $1,000 Down?
Lael Brainard’s group wants first-time buyers to get into a home with just $1,000 down. The goal is right, but the plan as written starts buyers underwater, makes other FHA borrowers pick up the cost, and could push starter-home prices higher. Here’s my take, and how I’d fix it.

Matthew Gardner
Nov 116 min read


Are Puget Sound Housing Inventories Still Rising as the Market Heads into the Winter? (October 2026)
Short Answer: Yes, compared with a year ago. October active listings were up about 31% from a year ago across King, Snohomish, and Pierce counties, while closed and pending sales both fell by roughly 17%. Prices are softer, but the real story is how much slower buyers are moving. Brokers have been telling me the same thing for months now. There is plenty of inventory out there, but buyers are taking their time. The October numbers back that up: inventory is up sharply and sal

Matthew Gardner
Nov 64 min read


Democrats Have Taken Control of the House and Senate: What Does This Mean for Housing?
The Short Answer: For the U.S. housing market, a Democratic Congress means more oversight and tougher funding fights, but far less change than the headlines suggest. Democrats now run every committee as well as Senate confirmations, but without a veto-proof majority they can’t pass major housing, spending, or tax bills on their own. I expect closer scrutiny of Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, and the FHFA, a bigger Democratic say over HUD and voucher funding, and better odds for a fe

Matthew Gardner
Nov 517 min read


How Big Is Washington State’s Housing Shortage?
Short Answer: It depends on which shortage you mean! Washington has under built by more than 175,000 homes since 2010, and outside estimates of today’s backlog run from 140,000 to 250,000. Separately, the state says we need to add about 1.1 million homes between 2020 and 2044. Using that target, we kept pace for the first six years, but barely. Production is now falling fast and, without policy changes, its not unreasonable to think that the deficit could top 300,000 by 2045.

Matthew Gardner
Nov 45 min read
How Does Housing Affect the Broader Economy?
Short Answer: Housing accounts for roughly one-sixth of the U.S. economy with spending split between building and remodeling homes, and the ongoing cost of occupying homes (rent, owners’ equivalent rent, and utilities). That said, its real power is indirect. Home equity drives consumer spending, mortgage rates set how much people buy, build, and borrow, and residential construction has been the most reliable early warning of recession for more than half a century! I've been a

Matthew Gardner
Nov 43 min read


Why Does it Cost So Much to Build a Home in Washington State?
Short Answer: Land, labor and materials explain much of it, but Washington adds an unusually heavy layer of regulatory cost on top. One recent estimate puts that layer at roughly $204,000, or 29.5% of the median new home price, compared with about 26% nationally. Because most of those costs are charged per unit, they land hardest on the entry-level homes the state needs most. Brokers, builders and legislators often tell me that they talk to home buyers who see a new townhom

Matthew Gardner
Oct 304 min read
Looking For a Housing Economist to Speak at Your Event?
Short answer: Matthew Gardner is a housing and real estate economist who has advised on housing markets since 1999 and serves on the Washington State Governor’s Council of Economic Advisors. He delivers data-driven forecasts for conferences, associations, lenders, builders and corporate events, in person or virtually. Check availability Matthew Gardner delivers a keynote presentation for brokers of The Agency where he gives his expectations for the global economy and housing

Matthew Gardner
Oct 292 min read
Are people moving out of Seattle and Washington State?
Short answer: No. Washington is still gaining people from elsewhere. In the year to April 1, 2026, 43,870 more people moved into the state than moved out, and Seattle grew by 6,800 residents to 823,400, according to the state Office of Financial Management (OFM). However, what has changed is the pace, and who is coming and going. High housing costs are pushing young families out of the city, to the suburbs and beyond. If you work with buyers and sellers, that distinction ma

Matthew Gardner
Oct 295 min read
Rent or Buy in Seattle? An Economist's Honest Answer
Short answer: Right now, on the numbers alone, renting beats buying for most Seattle households, whether the home is a house or a condo. That is not a forever answer, and it is not the answer for everyone. It is what the math says in late October 2026, with mortgage rates above 7% and a Seattle single-family house selling for about 22 times its annual rent. This is a question I get asked more than just about any other and I know that brokers get asked it weekly. Unfortunately

Matthew Gardner
Oct 294 min read
Are baby boomers aging in place “blocking” housing supply?
Short Answer: "Partly”, but “blocking” actually overstates it. They're a symptom of the shortage, though, not its cause, and blaming them lets the real culprit off the hook. I get this question at nearly every talk I give, usually from a broker who just lost another listing appointment to a couple in their 70s who decided to "stay a few more years." The frustration is fair. Empty-nest boomers sit on a big share of the country's family-sized homes, and they're moving far less

Matthew Gardner
Oct 296 min read
What is the ROAD to Housing Act and What Will it Do?
Short Answer: The 21st Century ROAD to Housing Act became law on July 11, 2026 and is the most significant federal housing legislation in more than a decade. The law rewards local governments that make it easier to build, loosens federal rules for manufactured homes and small apartment buildings, and stops the largest investors from buying more existing single-family homes. That said, it does not override local zoning. The headline provisions are: Up to $200 million a year in

Matthew Gardner
Oct 287 min read
Will First-Time Buyers be Priced Out For Good?
Short answer: No, not for good. But "not for good" is a long way from "soon," and without real change on supply, a lot of today's would-be buyers will get there years later than their parents did, with less equity to show for it. The headline numbers are bleak. The National Association of Realtors' (NAR) Profile of Home Buyers and Sellers (2025) put first-time buyers at 21% of purchases, the lowest share since NAR started tracking in 1981. Before 2008, that figure ran closer

Matthew Gardner
Oct 285 min read
bottom of page